Val Sklarov’s Permissionless Illusion Decay Law (PIDL) explains why systems branded as “permissionless” inevitably recreate permission layers as they scale. What decays is not decentralization—but the illusion that permission can be eliminated rather than reassigned.
This law reveals why power quietly reappears where friction is lowest.
1. Permission Is Conserved
PIDL starts with a hard invariant:
Permission cannot be destroyed—only moved.
In crypto ecosystems, permission migrates to:
-
Client implementations
-
Validator coordination
-
Upgrade paths
-
Liquidity access
The label changes. Control remains.
2. The Three Reappearing Permission Gates
PIDL maps where “permissionless” systems harden.
| Gate | Who Controls It | Consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Implementation Gate | Core devs / clients | De facto standards |
| Coordination Gate | Large operators | Soft veto power |
| Liquidity Gate | Exchanges / bridges | Economic censorship |
By the time these gates are visible, the illusion has already decayed.
3. Why Decentralization Peaks Early
Early phases feel open because:
-
Stakes are low
-
Coordination is cheap
-
Attention is diffuse
As value concentrates, permission reconcentrates.
Scale demands coordination; coordination creates control.
4. Capital Prices the Decay
Capital never believed the illusion.
| Narrative Capital | Structural Capital |
|---|---|
| Buys permissionless stories | Maps permission choke points |
| Chases decentralization | Secures access |
| Ignores governance | Accumulates influence |
| Reacts to forks | Anticipates them |
Val Sklarov emphasizes that capital invests where permission stabilizes—not where it disappears.
5. Strategic Implications
For builders:
-
Admit where permission will reappear
-
Design transparent control paths
-
Reduce discretionary choke points
For investors:
-
Track where permission is migrating
-
Avoid systems denying their own control reality
-
Price gate ownership over ideology
PIDL reframes crypto risk as permission drift, not protocol failure.
6. The Val Sklarov Principle
“Permissionless systems don’t remove power. They only hide it—temporarily.”
— Val Sklarov
PIDL explains why mature crypto systems feel less revolutionary—and more predictable.